Prepare the roast. Use a sharp knife to remove any obvious strips of fat on the outside of the roast; they should come off very easily.
Optional: To create extra flavor, brown the roast on all sides in a medium-sized skillet over medium heat. Add the oil to the skillet, then place the roast into the skillet, browning for 3-5 minutes, or until the meat releases from the pan. Flip and brown the other side for 3-5 minutes. Finally, use tongs to brown the thinner sides of the roast.
Deglaze the pan. Remove the roast from the skillet and pour in 1 cup of beef broth to deglaze the pan, scraping up any browned bits with the bottom of a wooden spoon. Remove from heat.
Seasoning. Place the roast into the slow cooker and sprinkle it on all sides with the ranch dressing and au jus mixes. Pour in the liquid from deglazing (or ½ cup of beef broth if you did not brown the roast first).
Add pepperoncini peppers (without the juices/pickling liquid).
Cut the butter into 5 pieces and scatter them over the top of the roast.
Cook on low. Place the lid on the slow cooker and cook on low for 8-9 hours.
Once the meat is fully cooked (with a minimum internal temperature of 145ºF/63ºC), remove it from the crock and set it on a large platter or cutting board.
Shred and soak. Shred the meat, then return it to the liquid to soak up the juices for 5-10 minutes.
Serve with your choice of mashed potatoes, rice, cooked noodles, or your favorite side dishes. It also makes for fabulous sandwiches!
Notes
If you can't find ranch dressing mix, use my recipe for homemade ranch seasoning instead. This recipe was adapted and inspired by the original recipe, which was submitted to a church cookbook by Robin Chapman. It has become world-famous ever since!
Au jus substitute: If you can't find au jus mix you can use brown gravy mix or onion soup mix.
With potatoes and carrots: Add 1 ½ pounds of baby potatoes and 12 ounces of baby carrots to the slow cooker about halfway through the cooking time. Stir well to ensure they are covered in juices. They should cook for 4-5 hours along with the roast.
Sandwiches: Shred the meat and serve on a toasted brioche bun or sourdough bread. Serve with prepared horseradish (or horseradish mayo) for extra zing!
Storage and reheating: Transfer leftovers to an airtight container and store in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days. Reheat portions as needed in the microwave, or in a skillet with additional broth added to keep the meat moist. Heat until the meat reaches a minimum internal temperature of 145ºF (63ºC).