Copycat McDonald’s Shamrock Shake

Are you craving a McDonald’s Shamrock Shake? Well, what if I told you that you could make it at home!? You can with just 4 simple ingredients. Perfect for St. Patrick’s Day or for indulging in your minty obsession any time of year.

Please note that some of my blog posts here at Dash for Dinner may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I will get a small commission at no additional cost to you. Please see my Disclaimer for more information.

---

When my husband and I were home shopping 5 years ago, we had a lot of trouble finding one that wasn’t creepy, whilst still staying within our price range. There were a few that were perfect, but sold before we could get an offer in. It was a difficult time, since we wanted a place of our own so badly!

Finally, a house we had been interested in came back on the market after a dreaded pending offer. We were so excited, since this was the one we really felt called to just by looking at the listing! Well, long story short, we knew it was “the one”, and put on an offer within 24 hours. After viewing the home, we took a trip to a nearby town and enjoyed a delicious Shamrock Shake at the local McDonald’s.

Now, 5 years later, we still enjoy our yearly Shamrock Shake every year at that same McDonald’s. It’s become a tradition for us, and it reminds me of that significant time in our lives.

Recently, I got to thinking: what if they discontinued the Shamrock Shake or shut down our local McDonald’s? Could we still continue on with this beloved tradition?

And so, the idea for this yummy St. Patrick’s Day inspired recipe was born! I hope you enjoy this tasty recipe as much as we did, and I hope it evokes as many fond memories for you as it does for us.

Let’s get started!

Ingredients

• Ice Cream: You will need 2 1/2 cups of your favorite vanilla ice cream. I’ve used vanilla bean, as well as a standard vanilla and the more generic vanilla ice cream does taste more like the real thing!
• Milk: Just a little but of milk to create a thinner consistency. You may wish to add more if you like a liquidy Shamrock Shake.
• Mint Extract: While peppermint will work in a pinch, you really want the standard “mint” extract to get the authentic experience.
• Food Coloring: You will need some green food coloring to get that signature green hue.

How to Make a Shamrock Shake at Home

Add your ice cream to the jug of a high powered blender (this is the budget model I own).

Pour in your milk.

Add in the green food coloring, as well as the mint extract.

Blend until smooth, and check for consistency. If you would like your shake to be thicker, add more ice cream. If you would like it thinner, go ahead and add a splash more of milk before blending again.

Serve and enjoy with a dollop of whipped cream, if desired. I prefer mine without, since that’s how they are served when you buy them at McDonald’s!

Variations

Shamrock Shake with Mint Ice Cream: Replace the vanilla ice cream for mint ice cream, and omit the mint extract called for in the recipe. Taste and adjust, adding vanilla extract if needed.

With Chocolate: Top your shake with whipped cream and drizzle with chocolate sauce. Top with chocolate shavings or curls, if desired.

With Protein: Add 1 scoop of your favorite vanilla-flavored whey protein powder.

Dairy Free: Substitute the ice cream for a non-dairy ice cream, and substitute the milk for cashew milk or a nut milk of your choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

More St. Patrick’s Day Inspired Recipes

• Lucky Charms Treats
• Lucky Charms Cookies – Fresh April Flours
• Leprechaun Bait – Kitchen Fun with my 3 Sons
• Pot of Gold Cupcakes – Baking a Moment
• Shamrock Gummies – The Best Ideas for Kids

Pin it for Later